Shingle-and-stone entry with a Dutch door and dormers on a 1929 Colonial Revival home in Westfield, New Jersey, renovated by Ellie Mroz Design and Michael Robert Construction.

Whole-Floor Renovation + Furnishings · Westfield, New Jersey

Bricks and Stones: A 1929 Stone-and-Shingle Kitchen and Mudroom Renovation in Westfield, NJ

A gracious 1929 Colonial Revival had space, wood and light in abundance — and almost no warmth, openness or flow. Featured in This Old House.

Lots of space. Lots of wood. Lots of light. This 1929 stone-and-shingle Colonial Revival in Westfield, New Jersey had all three and still did not work: a sprawling kitchen wing with too little openness, too little function, too little flow, and almost no warmth.

The homeowner cooks seriously and wanted a kitchen that was a hub the whole family could be in at once, open to the park-like setting outside. The old one was stuffy, closed in by walls of 1990s glazed-maple cabinetry.

We were brought in to rethink the existing footprint rather than extend it — kitchen, breakfast room, mudroom, bath and laundry — and to trade that maple for a mix of finishes that echo what the house already had: original wood-paneled walls, handsome moldings and weathered-brick exterior accents. This Old House published the result in its Summer 2023 issue.

Project Snapshot

Location
Westfield, New Jersey
The House
1929 stone-and-shingle Colonial Revival
Project Type
Whole-floor renovation within the existing footprint
Construction
Michael Robert Construction
Interior Design / Selections
Ellie Mroz Design
Rooms
Kitchen, breakfast room, mudroom, portico entry, full bath, laundry closet, outdoor snack bar and patio dining
Signature Elements
Arched openings, brick-paver herringbone floors, Dutch door entry, zinc vent hood trimmed with brass, two-sided fireplace, folding multi-panel window
Press
This Old House, Summer 2023

Cooking up togetherness

One wall of the kitchen is given over to cooking: a pro-style range under a zinc vent hood trimmed with brass, with cabinets below for pots and pans and appliance-lift shelves so the air fryer and the toaster live out of sight.

The island carries the main sink and a table section that seats six, which is where homework, snacks and a good many meals actually happen. A brick niche with open shelves sits between built-in freezer and refrigerator columns and echoes the mudroom floor, so the two rooms read as one idea.

Cabinet finishes are varied deliberately rather than matched — tall blue-green cabinets that echo the arched doorways against a white marble backsplash and base cabinets, with honed granite counters and new red oak floors laid to match the rest of the house. A double pendant, simple sconces and undercabinet lighting give the room layers instead of one flat wash.

Remaking an entrance

A fieldstone path off the driveway leads to a portico, and that is the door the family actually uses — arms full of groceries, children in tow, close to both the kitchen and the mudroom. The original slate roof was repaired rather than replaced, and the siding shingles were repaired or swapped and repainted.

A new Dutch door opens onto a floor of brick pavers laid in herringbone. Turn right for the kitchen, left for the mudroom. A run of new arched openings carries the sight lines through the whole sequence, which is what makes a set of small service rooms feel like one continuous space.

A mudroom that hides the sport of it

The brief for the mudroom was blunt: make it all about the children’s things, and keep those things out of sight. This is a household of athletes and a dancer, which means a great deal of footwear.

Tall cabinets take it, their doors finished with leather pulls that echo the leather bench in the middle of the room. There is storage for art supplies and gift wrap, and a fridge kept full of grab-and-go snacks. The apron-front sink doubles as a cleanup station for muddy cleats. Crisp white shiplap and marble counters keep the dark blue cabinetry and the brick floor from closing the room in.

Indoor-outdoor dining

The old breakfast room had a shed roof, skylights and wraparound windows, and it felt like a greenhouse. A flat, beamed ceiling and a fireplace settle it, without giving up the view.

Decorative oak beams, a two-sided gas fireplace and a generous oval table do the work indoors. The real move is the foldaway multi-panel window above a row of base cabinets holding a refrigerator drawer, tableware and an ice maker. Open it and food, drinks and place settings pass straight through to the granite snack bar outside — so anyone wet from the pool can stay where they are and still be fed.

The fireplace is two-sided by design and is enjoyed from the patio dining area as well. The fieldstone for its chimney was sourced to match the stone already on the house, which is the detail that keeps a new element from announcing itself.

Beauty and the bath

The full bath across from the mudroom was gutted and fitted with a walk-in shower for cleaning up after the pool, rebuilt on a slightly smaller footprint so a separate laundry closet could go in across from it.

The pale celadon vanity takes a marble top and a washstand-style backsplash with curved sides. Three birds crown the mirror frame, an homage to the children of the house. Touches of marble — the vanity top, the floor, the shower tile — are what make even a small bath feel luxurious.

More from this home

Renovating an older Westfield home that has the space but not the flow? The fix is usually the plan, not the square footage.

start a project

Built With

Michael Robert Construction

Design and construction on this project were coordinated together — architecture, site work and finish carpentry alongside the selections and furnishings.

See the construction side at Michael Robert Construction

Questions

Questions we get a lot

What was renovated in this Westfield home?

The kitchen, breakfast room, mudroom, a full bath and a new laundry closet, all within the existing footprint of a 1929 stone-and-shingle Colonial Revival. The mudroom now occupies what had been a scullery kitchen, and a new portico and Dutch door made the family’s everyday entrance work properly.

How do you open up a 1929 house without losing its character?

By borrowing its own vocabulary. Here that meant arched openings carrying the sight lines between kitchen, entry and mudroom, brick pavers echoing the weathered brick already on the exterior, red oak floors laid to match the rest of the house, and fieldstone for the new chimney sourced to match the existing stone.

What makes a kitchen work as a family hub?

Somewhere to be that is not in the cook’s way. This island carries the main sink plus a table section seating six, so homework and snacks happen alongside the cooking rather than in another room. A wall dedicated to the range keeps the working zone separate from the gathering one.

What is the point of a folding window in a breakfast room?

It turns a wall into a pass-through. Opened over a run of base cabinets holding a refrigerator drawer, tableware and an ice maker, it lets food and drinks go straight out to the snack bar and the pool terrace, so people wet from swimming never come through the house.

How should a mudroom be designed for a busy family?

For volume and for concealment. Tall cabinets swallow the sneakers, a bench gives somewhere to sit and pull them off, an apron-front sink handles muddy cleats, and a snack fridge keeps the kitchen from becoming a thoroughfare. Brick pavers underfoot take the traffic.